"Unfair dismissal" is what most people call it, but the actual legal term in New Zealand is unjustified dismissal. Here's what actually makes a dismissal unjustified, what you could get if you win, and an important change that now blocks some people from claiming at all.
The legal test
Section 103A of the Employment Relations Act asks one central question: was what your employer did, and how they did it, what a fair and reasonable employer could have done in the circumstances? This is an objective test - it's not about whether your specific employer thought they were being fair, it's about the standard a reasonable employer would be held to.
A dismissal can be unjustified for two different kinds of reasons, and either one is enough on its own:
- Substantively unjustified - there wasn't a genuine, good reason for the dismissal in the first place
- Procedurally unjustified - even if there was a valid reason, your employer didn't follow a fair process
The four things the process gets judged on
When deciding whether the process was fair, the law specifically looks at whether your employer:
- Sufficiently investigated the situation before dismissing you, given the resources they had
- Raised their concerns with you before making the decision
- Gave you a genuine, reasonable opportunity to respond
- Actually considered your response with an open mind, rather than having already decided
One important caveat: minor or inconsequential process defects on their own don't automatically make a dismissal unjustified - only if the defects meant you were actually treated unfairly. So a small paperwork issue that didn't change the outcome usually isn't enough by itself; a genuinely missed step that denied you a fair chance to respond usually is.
A new restriction that started in February 2026
Since 21 February 2026, if you earn $200,000 or more a year, you can no longer raise a personal grievance for unjustified dismissal, or for unjustified disadvantage relating to a dismissal, at all. This doesn't affect other grievance types like discrimination, harassment, or unpaid wages - those remain open to everyone regardless of income. If you were already on an existing agreement earning above this threshold, there's a 12-month transition period before this restriction applies to you.
What you could get if your grievance succeeds
- Lost wages - reimbursement for income you lost because of the dismissal, commonly up to about three months' pay, though the Employment Relations Authority or Employment Court can award more in some cases
- Compensation for hurt and humiliation - a separate payment for the personal impact of the dismissal (loss of dignity, injury to feelings), typically somewhere in the range of a few thousand to the low tens of thousands of dollars depending on severity
- Reinstatement - getting your job back, though this is less commonly sought or awarded than the financial remedies
If your own conduct played a part
The Employment Relations Amendment Act 2026 changed what happens when your own behaviour contributed to the situation. Since 21 February 2026:
- If your conduct amounted to serious misconduct, no remedies are available at all, even if the dismissal itself was handled unfairly (section 123B).
- If you contributed to the situation in any way, even short of serious misconduct, you can't get reinstatement or compensation for hurt and humiliation, loss of dignity and injury to feelings (section 123C). Other remedies, such as lost wages, may still be available.
- Any remaining remedy can be reduced to reflect your contribution, and that reduction can now be up to 100% (section 124).
So the remedies listed above are not all automatically on the table - how your own conduct is viewed can make a big difference to what you can actually get.
Raising it
Unjustified dismissal is raised as a personal grievance, so the standard 90-day deadline applies, running from your last day of employment. See our complete guide to employment disputes for exactly how that's calculated and what your options are if you're close to the deadline.
Getting help
If you think your dismissal wasn't handled fairly, either in substance or in process, KiwiClaims can help you understand your situation and put together a clear, well-structured letter to raise your grievance.
KiwiClaims provides general information based on the Employment Relations Act 2000 and current Employment NZ guidance. Current as at September 2026 - always verify current information at employment.govt.nz. Not legal advice. Independent of Employment NZ and the Employment Relations Authority.