← All guides

Constructive Dismissal NZ - When Resigning Counts as Being Dismissed (2026)

24 September 2026 · 4 min read · Dismissal & Trial Periods

If your workplace became so bad that resigning felt like the only option, the law may treat that resignation as a dismissal - but proving it is harder than most people expect, and it's worth understanding why before you hand in your notice.

What constructive dismissal actually is

The Employment Relations Act doesn't use the term "constructive dismissal" directly, but it's well established through case law. It's when you resign, but your employer's actions (or failure to act) left you with no real choice - so the law treats your resignation as if your employer dismissed you. You can then raise a personal grievance for unjustified dismissal, the same as if you'd been sacked outright.

The three situations this usually covers

  • "Resign or be dismissed." Your employer gives you an ultimatum - quit now, or we'll fire you. Being pressured into "choosing" to resign this way is treated as a dismissal.
  • A serious breach by your employer. Your employer seriously breaches your employment agreement or a fundamental duty they owe you - not paying wages, ignoring safety issues, or a similarly substantial breach - and you resign because of it.
  • A course of conduct that made resignation foreseeable. Your employer doesn't need to have intended for you to quit. The question the Employment Relations Authority asks is whether it was foreseeable that their conduct carried a substantial risk of causing your resignation.

The one thing everyone underestimates: the burden of proof

In a normal dismissal case, your employer has to prove they were justified in dismissing you. In a constructive dismissal case, it's the other way around - the burden is on you to prove that your resignation genuinely wasn't a free choice. That's a meaningfully harder position to argue from, which is exactly why constructive dismissal claims are known to be harder to win than straightforward dismissal claims.

Before you resign: get advice first if you can

If your employer has said something like "resign, or we'll have to let you go," it's worth pausing. Resigning can sometimes weaken your position rather than protect it, especially if you resign before getting a clear picture of your options. If you're not already mid-crisis and have any time at all, getting advice before you resign - not after - puts you in a much stronger position than trying to reconstruct the situation afterward.

The same deadline applies

Constructive dismissal is raised as a personal grievance for unjustified dismissal, so the standard 90-day deadline applies, running from your actual last day of employment. See our complete guide to employment disputes for how that deadline is calculated and what happens if you're close to running out of time.

Building your case

Because the burden is on you, documentation matters more here than in almost any other type of personal grievance. Useful evidence includes:

  • Written records of what was said to you (emails, texts, meeting notes you wrote up afterward)
  • A timeline of what happened and when, especially if it built up over time rather than being one incident
  • Anything showing you raised concerns before resigning, and how your employer responded (or didn't)

Getting help

If you've resigned, or are considering it, because your workplace situation became untenable, KiwiClaims can help you understand whether your situation has the makings of a constructive dismissal case and put together a clear letter setting out your position.

Check what you can claim →

KiwiClaims provides general information based on the Employment Relations Act 2000 and current Employment NZ guidance. Current as at September 2026 - always verify current information at employment.govt.nz. Not legal advice. Independent of Employment NZ and the Employment Relations Authority.

Related guides