← All guides

ACC Review vs Appeal: What's the Difference (2026 Guide)

5 August 2026 · 7 min read · Appeals

If ACC has declined your claim, stopped a payment, or made a decision you disagree with, your first step is almost never an appeal - it's a review. The two get used interchangeably in conversation, but they're different processes, at different stages, with different rules. Getting this wrong costs time you may not have, since both stages have strict deadlines.

Step 1: The ACC Review

When you receive a decision letter from ACC that you disagree with, you can apply for an independent review. This is the first formal dispute step.

  • Who runs it: An independent reviewer, not ACC staff - contracted but separate from the corporation.
  • Deadline: You generally have 3 months from the date of the decision letter to apply.
  • How it works: You (or your representative) submit a review application, gather supporting evidence - usually medical reports - and attend a review hearing, often by phone or video.
  • Cost: Free to apply. If you engage paid help (a lawyer or advocate) and the review goes in your favour, costs can often be reclaimed from ACC under the Review Costs Regulations. These regulations were updated in late 2025, with fewer cost categories and higher caps, so check the current amounts with ACC or an advocate.
  • Outcome: The reviewer can uphold ACC's decision, overturn it, or send it back to ACC for reconsideration.

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR): an option instead of a hearing

Alongside the formal review, ACC also offers Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) - a broad term covering mediation, conciliation, and facilitation. Instead of presenting your case to an independent reviewer at a hearing, ADR puts you and ACC in a structured conversation with a neutral third party, aiming to reach an agreed outcome without a formal decision being handed down.

It tends to suit disputes where the disagreement is more about communication, process, or a specific misunderstanding than a hard factual or medical dispute - those often still need a full review, since ADR relies on both sides being willing to move. You can raise ADR as an option when you apply for a review; it's not a separate application process, but an alternative way of resolving the one you've already started.

Step 2: The ACC Appeal

If the independent review doesn't go your way, the next step is an appeal to the District Court.

  • Who runs it: A judge, in a formal court setting.
  • Deadline: Generally 28 days from the review decision.
  • How it works: This is a legal proceeding - most people engage a lawyer at this stage, since it involves formal legal argument, not just supporting evidence.
  • Cost: Significantly higher than a review, and less commonly recoverable unless you're fully successful.

We cover this stage in detail, including what to expect and how to prepare, in our step-by-step guide to appealing an ACC decision.

Why the distinction matters

The most common mistake we see is people treating "review" and "appeal" as the same thing and missing the earlier, easier deadline. A review is faster, cheaper, and has a lower bar than an appeal - most disputes are resolved (one way or another) at this stage, and never reach the District Court at all. Skipping straight to thinking about "appealing" can mean losing the 3-month review window while you're still figuring out what to do. The same window applies to a vocational independence decision, where the review clock and the three-month payment run-off start on the same day.

Getting your review application right

Because the review is where most cases are actually decided, the quality of what you submit matters more than people expect. ACC's original decision was based on the information it had - reviews often succeed or fail on whether new or clearer evidence is presented, and whether your explanation of why the decision was wrong is specific rather than general.

This is exactly the kind of document KiwiClaims's claim letter and document review tools are built for - turning your situation and evidence into a clear, structured submission for $19–$49 NZD, without needing a consultation first. If your case is more complex - disputed medical causation, a large compensation amount, or you're already past review and into appeal territory - that's when it's worth bringing in an ACC advocate or lawyer. See our guide to free vs paid ACC advocates for how to weigh that decision.


Related: ACC Claims NZ: The Complete Guide (2026) - our full hub guide to cover, entitlements, payments and disputes.

Related guides